# What is the current social cost of carbon?

\$50 per ton

## How is social cost of carbon determined?

1. What is the social cost of carbon? The short answer: The social cost of carbon is the cost of the damages created by one extra ton of carbon dioxide emissions.2021-06-07

## How does carbon help society?

Carbon is in carbon dioxide, which is a greenhouse gas that works to trap heat close to Earth. It helps Earth hold the energy it receives from the Sun so it doesn’t all escape back into space. If it weren’t for carbon dioxide, Earth’s ocean would be frozen solid.

## How much is 20lbs of CO2?

A gallon of gas = 20 pounds of CO2!

## What is the current cost of carbon?

According to their estimates, the current weighted carbon price is \$34.99 (as of June 2021), which is up from around \$20 near the end of 2020. Before December of 2020, the IHS Markit Global Carbon Index calculation of carbon credit cost had not risen above \$22.15.

## How much does CO2 cost?

The social cost of carbon is a measure of the economic harm from those impacts, expressed as the dollar value of the total damages from emitting one ton of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. The current central estimate of the social cost of carbon is over \$50 per ton in today’s dollars.

## What are the social cost of carbon emission?

The social cost of carbon is an estimate of the economic costs, or damages, of emitting one additional ton of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere, and thus the benefits of reducing emissions. The estimate informs billions of dollars of policy and investment decisions in the United States and abroad.2021-09-08

## Is CO2 expensive?

However, industrial CO2 for use in various industries is still relatively expensive. The price of industrial CO2 in a 1 MT tank is approximately US\$250 per metric ton (MT) and that of a 100 lb tank is over US\$1,500 per MT.2020-06-04

## Why is CO2 so expensive?

The mass of CO2 produced is 2-3 times the mass of coal or methane* burned and is more challenging per unit to ship than coal, so the cost of capture, distribution and sequestration is typically a multiple of the cost of doing the same with the coal or methane.2016-01-19

## How much does CO2 cost per ton?

The average global carbon price is around \$3 per ton of CO2; Only 4% of global emissions are priced above \$40 per ton. At those prices, companies and governments are not incentivized to pay for emission reductions.2021-07-14

around \$51 a ton

## What is social and private cost?

Private costs are the costs facing individual decision-makers based on actual market prices. Social costs are the private costs plus the costs of externalities. The prices are derived from market prices, where opportunity costs are taken into account.

175 cubic feet

## How does carbon affect the community?

Carbon emissions directly affect humans, too, causing more respiratory disease from an increase of smog and air pollution. Not to mention that if carbon emissions eradicate certain animal species, destroy crop yields and lands, humans will also see the repercussions of those effects as well.2020-03-30

## What is social cost in environment?

The social cost of carbon (SCC) is an estimate, in dollars, of the economic damages that would result from emitting one additional ton of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere.

## What is social value carbon?

The marginal damage cost of emissions also termed the ‘social cost of carbon’ (SCC) –, or. The marginal abatement cost (MAC) of reducing emissions or sequestering carbon, or. The carbon price or pollution tax required to meet a given climate stabilisation goal.

\$51 per ton

## How is the social cost of carbon used?

The social cost of carbon (SCC) is used to estimate in dollars all economic damage that would result from emitting one ton of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. It indicates how much it is worth to us today to avoid the damage that is projected for the future.2021-04-01

### Live Carbon Prices Today, Carbon Price Charts • Carbon Credits

Live Carbon Prices Today, Carbon Price Charts • Carbon Credits Live Carbon Prices Today Trending Right Now The 3 Best Carbon Stocks of 2022 How to Make Money Producing and Selling Carbon Offsets CarbonCredits.com Real-time Pricing (Updates Every 5 Mins) Mandatory Compliance Market Carbon Pricing

### Carbon needs to cost at least \$100/tonne now to reach net

Recommendations ranged from \$50 to \$250. “Current carbon prices in G20 economies are between \$3-\$60 per tonne of carbon emissions, but many large emerging economies like Brazil, India, Indonesia

### The true cost of carbon pollution | Environmental Defense Fund

The current central estimate of the social cost of carbon is over \$50 per ton in today’s dollars. While this is the most robust and credible figure available, it does not yet include all of the widely recognized and accepted scientific and economic impacts of climate change.

### Carbon Pricing Dashboard | Up-to-date overview of carbon

Note: Only the introduction or removal of an ETS or carbon tax is shown. The coverage of each carbon pricing initiative is presented as a share of annual global GHG emissions for 1990-2015 based on data from the Emission Database for Global Atmospheric Research (EDGAR) version 5.0 including biofuels emissions.

### Social Cost of Carbon: What Is It, and Why Do We Need to

In their paper’s scenario, the researchers found that carbon prices of \$32, \$52 and \$93 per metric ton (in 2018 U.S. dollars), if implemented in 2025, would achieve net-zero targets in 2060, 2050 and 2040, respectively.

### Carbon Credit Pricing Chart: Updated September 2022

The World Bank, who compiles a yearly report on carbon credit pricing in the carbon marketplace, also noted the following: Most prices of carbon credits are below the \$40-80 per metric ton of carbon dioxide emitted needed to keep global warming within a 2-point degree, as provided by the Paris agreement. 4. Higher prices are required to achieve

### What is Carbon Pricing? | Carbon Pricing Dashboard

carbon pricing is an instrument that captures the external costs of greenhouse gas (ghg) emissions—the costs of emissions that the public pays for, such as damage to crops, health care costs from heat waves and droughts, and loss of property from flooding and sea level rise—and ties them to their sources through a price, usually in the form of a …

### Carbon offset prices set to increase tenfold by 2030

carbon offset prices on average stand at just \$3-5 per metric ton of co2 at present, with experts fearing that prices are far below the level required to both unlock significant investment in emissions-mitigation measures, such as carbon removal technologies or large scale nature-based solution projects, and provide companies with an additional …

### Biden Administration Sets Social Cost Of Carbon At \$51 Per Ton

Initially, the social cost of carbon will be set by the Biden administration at \$51 per ton, according to a report by the Washington Post. Gina McCarthy, Biden’s national climate adviser, said that

READ  What did the women’s rights movement accomplish in the 19th century?

### How Much Do Carbon Offsets Cost – Prices – What It Costs

How Much Do Carbon Offsets Cost – Prices Ballpark Estimate: \$5.50 to \$29 per ton of CO2 Protecting the environment has become big business in the 21st century. Everywhere you look, there are eco-friendly products and services that promise to save the planet and make you feel good about being part of the global effort.

### Cost of Carbon Pollution Pegged at \$51 a Ton – Scientific

“There needs to be a consistency between the approaches used for the social cost of carbon and other regulatory actions,” said Richard Newell, president and CEO of Resources for the Future and

### Professors explain the social cost of carbon | Stanford News

The short answer: The Obama administration introduced the first estimated social cost of carbon and it was \$43 a ton. The Trump administration estimate was \$3-\$5 a ton, and the Biden administration estimate is around \$51 a ton. Most analysts tend to support the Obama administration’s estimate over the Trump administration’s.

### PDF Social Cost of Carbon Fact Sheet – US EPA

Social Cost of CO 2, 2015-2050 a (in 2007 dollars per metric ton CO 2) Source: Technical Support Document: Technical Update of the Social Cost of Carbon for Regulatory Impact Analysis Under Executive Order 12866 (May 2013, Revised August 2016) Discount Rate and Statistic Year 5% Average 3% Average 2.5% Average High Impact (3% 95 th percentile)

### Carbon pricing | Ember

Carbon pricing. The latest data on EU ETS carbon prices. Carbon Prices. Build web apps for free with. Built with. Anvil Built with. × Close. Title. Body.

### Pricing Carbon – World Bank

Carbon pricing is an essential part of the solution. The economic arguments for action are also compelling. Action now can open doors to opportunity, as the Adding Up the Benefits, New Climate Economy and Risky Business reports all reflect. Delaying action, the IPCC warns, will only raise the costs.

### The social cost of carbon – brookings.edu

The interagency working group currently uses an interim social cost of carbon of \$51 and is expected to announce an updated value for this critical estimate in a January 2022 report.

### The Social Cost of Carbon | Climate Change | US EPA

for example, the projected net present value of carbon dioxide mitigation benefits over the next forty years from three vehicle rulemakings was estimated to range from \$78 billion to \$1.2 trillion (\$2010), depending on which of the four sc-co 2 estimates were used (i.e., the average sc-co 2 at 5, 3, and 2.5 percent and the 95th percentile sc-co 2 …

### What is the 'social cost of carbon'? 2 energy experts explain

The Trump administration slashed the social cost to between \$1 and \$7 per metric ton of carbon dioxide – low enough that the administration could justify rolling back EPA regulations on power plant

### CARBON PRICING: What is a carbon credit worth? – Gold Standard

This means that for every tonne of carbon dioxide we emit into the atmosphere, we sacrifice between \$11 and \$212 in environmental degradation and negative social impacts. In theory, these should be accounted for in the price of a carbon credit. Fig. 2 Social Cost of CO2 2015-2050* (in 2007 dollars per metric ton)

### Carbon pricing – CDP

Carbon Pricing Connect is a data visualization tool featuring CDP’s extensive data on internal carbon pricing with respect to global regulatory policy. Reference the Carbon Pricing Leadership Coalition Resource Hub for external research on current and emerging carbon pricing practices tailored to a wide audience of stakeholders.

### Carbon price – Wikipedia

In 2020, carbon pricing generated \$53bn in revenue. According to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, a price level of \$135-5500 in 2030 and \$245-13000 per ton CO 2 in 2050 would be needed to drive carbon emissions to stay below the 1.5°C limit.

### Value Of Carbon Market Update 2020 – Carbon Credit Capital

According to IHS Markit’s Global Carbon Index, which is made up of prices from the California Compliance Allowance, RGGI, and European Allowance prices, the current weighted global price on carbon is equivalent to \$20.81 USD (shown in the chart below). The World Bank’s data comes out with a similar price across its 61 jurisdictions at \$20

### The Use of Current Social Cost of Carbon Estimates in

Subsequent essays will compare current social cost of carbon estimates with alternative approaches, including a new proposal, and provide initial empirical estimates. By 1960, the number of American deaths from car accidents had been climbing for seven decades to top 50,000 Americans annually, including thousands of children.

### Costs of carbon | The Economist

About half of current NDCs mention the idea. In 2010 about 5% of the world’s emissions were covered by a carbon price. In 2010 about 5% of the world’s emissions were covered by a carbon price

### Calculating the Social Cost of Greenhouse Gases – The Cost

Calculating the Social Cost of Greenhouse Gases. This tool lets users calculate the present value of economic damages from a given amount of greenhouse gas emissions using the Interagency Working Group’s 2021 interim estimates 1 and New York’s 2020 estimates. 2 All values are in 2020\$.

### Ten-fold increase in carbon offset cost predicted | UCL

The cost of offsetting corporate carbon emissions needs to increase ten-fold to drive meaningful climate action, says a landmark report by UCL and Trove Research. Current prices of carbon offsets are unsustainably low and need to increase significantly to encourage greater investment in new projects that remove carbon from the atmosphere.

### Carbon Market Prices – Renewable Energy Hub

Carbon & renewable energy market prices. CORE Markets provides access to live market pricing, as well as curve pricing where our expert team assesses the fair value across spot and forward markets in carbon, energy and environmental markets. Market prices for Australian Carbon Credit Units (ACCU), New Zealand Units (NZU), and Large-scale

### Levelised cost of CO2 capture by sector and initial CO2

Sources. IEA analysis based on own estimates and GCCSI (2017), Global costs of carbon capture and storage, 2017 update, IEAGHG (2014), CO2 capture at coal based power and hydrogen plants, Keith et al. (2018), A Process for Capturing CO2 from the Atmosphere, NETL (2014), Cost of capturing CO2 from Industrial sources, Rubin, E. S., Davison, J. E. and Herzog, H. J (2015), The cost of CO2 capture

### What is the current social cost of carbon

The social cost of carbon (SCC) is used to estimate in dollars all economic damage that would result from emitting one ton of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. Theoretically, the SCC should increase over time because physical and economic systems will become more stressed as the impacts of climate change accumulate.

### The Current Cost of Carbon – dailykos.com

“The current social cost of carbon pollution estimates for a unit of emissions in 2015 are \$57, \$37, and \$11 using discount rates of 2.5 percent, 3 percent, and 5 percent, respectively.

### Value Of Carbon Market Update 2021 – Carbon Credit Capital

According to their estimates, the current weighted carbon price is \$34.99 (as of June 2021), which is up from around \$20 near the end of 2020. Before December of 2020, the IHS Markit Global Carbon Index calculation of carbon credit cost had not risen above \$22.15. As mentioned in Pianpian Wang’s original article on this topic, 2021 marks the

READ  What is not allowed during Sabbath?

### Current cost of CO2 capture for carbon removal

Current cost of CO2 capture for carbon removal technologies by sector – Chart and data by the International Energy Agency. Current cost of CO2 capture for carbon removal technologies by sector – Chart and data by the International Energy Agency. Skip navigation. Countries. Find out about the world, a region, or a country

### Biden tried to change the social cost of carbon. What does

New York state uses a 2% discount rate to produce its current social cost of carbon of \$125 per ton. Some analysts argue for a 0% discount rate because anything higher places a lower value on

### Carbon Black Prices, News, Market & Analysis | ChemAnalyst

Carbon black is composed of fine particles of carbon. It is produced from incomplete combustion of natural gas or petroleum, primarily residual heavy fuel oil from petroleum refining, coal tar distillation and Ethylene at temperatures above 2000 deg Fahrenheit. Carbon Black Price, Carbon Black Prices, Carbon Black Pricing, Carbon Black Supply and Demand, Carbon Black Demand and Supply, Carbon

### Updating the United States Government's Social Cost of Carbon

Tamma Carleton, Michael Greenstone Since its release in 2010, the United States government’s Social Cost of Carbon (SCC) has played a central role in climate policy both domestically and internationally. However, rapid progress in climate science and economics over the last decade mean that it is no longer based on the frontier of understanding. Specifically,

### Court ruling on social cost of carbon upends Biden's

If Interior held a lease sale based on the current environmental analysis, Prentice-Dunn said, it could get struck down in court for relying on the higher interim social cost of carbon.

### MetalMiner Prices: Carbon Steel Prices

Get an accurate ‘should cost’ for carbon steel prices, available prices for different forms and grades of carbon steel from MetalMiner. Current Price: \$ 0.71 /lb . Cold-Rolled Coil. 50 ASTM

### Carbon Pricing – World Bank

And half of current emissions covered by carbon pricing initiatives are priced at less than \$10 per ton CO2e. This is far short of the level needed to drive transformational change: estimated at \$40-80 per ton by 2020 and \$50-100 per ton by 2030 according to the High-Level Commission on Carbon Prices, co-chaired by Joseph Stiglitz and Lord

### Social Cost of Carbon – Resources for the Future

The Social Cost of Carbon: Advances in Long-Term Probabilistic Projections of Population, GDP, Emissions, and Discount Rates. This paper, coauthored by scholars at RFF and top research universities, examines the key methods and challenges involved in estimating a more accurate social cost of carbon. Journal Article — .

### Biden administration puts a price on carbon | Ars Technica

So, the 3 percent discount rate sees the social cost of carbon hit \$85 by 2050. Methane and nitrous oxide are far more potent greenhouse gases, and their current social costs are astronomical in

### The Social Cost of Carbon: Trends, Outliers and

The Social Cost of Carbon: Trends, Outliers and Catastrophes. Estimates of the social cost of carbon (dioxide emissions), or the marginal damage cost of climate change are an essential ingredient to any assessment of climate policy. The Social Cost of Carbon: Trends, Outliers and Catastrophes (pdf) Contact Us to ask a question, provide feedback

### Levelized Cost of Carbon Abatement: An Improved Cost

Sub-case 2: To understand the costs of the federal ITC on carbon reduction, we estimate LCCA for power generated by a 10 kW rooftop array in each state and the carbon abatement costs with and without the current ITC of 26 percent. In the case with the ITC, we assume that the deployment of the rooftop array only occurs due to the ITC.

### CARBON PRICING: What is a carbon credit worth – Gold

This means that for every tonne of carbon dioxide we emit into the atmosphere, we sacrifice between \$11 and \$212 in environmental degradation and negative social impacts. In theory, these should be accounted for in the price of a carbon credit. Fig. 2 Social Cost of CO2 2015-2050* (in 2007 dollars per metric ton)

### Biden matches Obama's 'social cost of carbon' for now

The temporary figure calculates the social cost of carbon, adjusted for inflation, and is used by federal agencies. The report could help the Biden administration justify stricter emissions controls.

### Carbon capture and storage: how far can costs fall? | Wood

Costs will go up before they go down. Current global CCS capacity is around 60 Mtpa and could rise to 400 Mtpa by 2030. We estimate this will need to rise by as much as 10-15 times that number to meet our Accelerated Energy Transition scenarios. One thing that companies and governments will have to consider as they scale up and increase

### Social cost of carbon – Wikipedia

The social cost of carbon (SCC) is the marginal cost of the impacts caused by emitting one extra tonne of greenhouse gas (carbon dioxide equivalent) at any point in time, inclusive of ‘non-market’ impacts on the environment and human health. The purpose of putting a price on a ton of emitted CO 2 is to aid policymakers or other legislators in evaluating whether a policy designed to curb

### Carbon price – Wikipedia

Carbon pricing (or CO 2 pricing) also known as cap and trade (CAT) or emissions trading scheme (ETS) is a method for nations to reduce global warming.The cost is applied to greenhouse gas emissions in order to encourage polluters to reduce the combustion of coal, oil and gas – the main driver of climate change.The method is widely agreed and considered to be efficient.

### CO2 European Emission Allowances PRICE Today | CO2

CO2 European Emission Allowances Price: Get all information on the Price of CO2 European Emission Allowances including News, Charts and Realtime Quotes.

### Q&A: The social cost of carbon – Carbon Brief

Current US social cost of carbon estimates, for each year to 2050 in \$ per tonne of CO2. The US defines four values for the SCC. These are a high-impact figure (95th percentile value for a 3% discount rate, dark blue line) and average values for three discount rates of 2.5% (light blue), 3% (red) and 5% (grey).

### Study quantifies the mortality cost of carbon emissions

A just-published study coins a new metric: the “mortality cost of carbon.” That is, how many future lives will be lost–or saved–depending on whether we increase or decrease our current carbon

### Cheaper Carbon Capture Is on the Way – Marathon Research

PNNL-developed solvent breaks barriers, captures carbon for less than industrial counterparts. As part of a marathon research effort to lower the cost of carbon capture, chemists have now demonstrated a method to seize carbon dioxide (CO 2) that reduces costs by 19 percent compared to current commercial technology.The new technology requires 17 percent less energy to accomplish the same task

### Trump Put a Low Cost on Carbon Emissions. Here's Why It

But in 2016, the Obama administration recommended that federal agencies use a central estimate that, in current dollars, pegged the damage from a ton of carbon dioxide emitted in 2020 at around

READ  What are the 4 primal instincts?

### 10 Carbon Capture methods compared: costs, scalability

We need to understand carbon capture, storage and utilisation (CCUS) better. To do so, this article looks at 10 methods and estimates how much CO2 each will take out of the atmosphere by 2050, and the cost per tonne.In their list the authors, Ella Adlen and Cameron Hepburn at the University of Oxford, cover the industrial (e.g. CO2-EOR, synfuels) to the biological (e.g. forestry, soil carbon

### What is the true cost of carbon emissions? | Financial Times

The benchmark, which it plans to calculate daily, launches today using carbon prices based on trading under the three most liquid trading schemes: the EU’s, and two from the US.It uses data

### What is the 'Social Cost of Carbon'? – CounterPunch.org

New York state uses a 2% discount rate to produce its current social cost of carbon of \$125 per ton. Some analysts argue for a 0% discount rate because anything higher places a lower value on

### PDF GAO-20-254, SOCIAL COST OF CARBON: Identifying a Federal

Appendix II Current Federal Estimates of the Social Costs of Carbon Dioxide, Methane, and Nitrous Oxide 57 Appendix III Views of State Officials from Montana and Texas on the Social Cost of Carbon 59 Appendix IV Canada’s Social Cost of Carbon Approach to Developing Monetary Estimates for Greenhouse Gas Emissions 61

### CO2 emissions prices in the Northeast states reached

The most recent Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) quarterly auction, held on March 3, 2021, resulted in a clearing price of \$7.60 per short ton of carbon dioxide (CO2), surpassing the previous high price of \$7.50 per short ton reached in December 2015. States can reinvest the proceeds from these auctions in consumer benefit programs to improve energy efficiency and accelerate the

### PDF Global Costs of Carbon Capture and Storage

Global costs of carbon capture and storage – 2017 Update 1 Background This summary report presents data commissioned by the Global CCS Institute from Advisian (the consulting and advisory arm of WorleyParsons, a global engineering firm) of the current and likely future costs of CCS in power generation and industrial applications.

### An Insight into Current Prices of Woodland Carbon Units

An Insight into Current Prices of Woodland Carbon Units. The price you pay for a product is determined by the value you attach to it. For the seller of that same product, the price which they receive should broadly match the one paid, minus the transaction costs. In the woodland carbon market, those transaction costs are limited.

### Keep climate policy focused on the social cost of carbon

The costs of a climate policy are the abatement costs of reducing emissions of carbon dioxide (CO 2) (or other greenhouse gases). The standard measure of the benefits of a climate policy is the social cost of carbon (SCC), which measures the avoided economic damages associated with a metric ton of CO 2 emissions.

### How Much Does Steel Plate Cost: 2022? | Leeco Steel, LLC

The cost of steel plate and other steel materials is complex and fluctuating, as there are a number of factors that can impact price. This article has been updated as of March 2022 to reflect these factors. Steel is typically priced by hundredweight (CWT), which is the price per 100 pounds of material.

### Energy Department Aims to Slash Cost of Removing Carbon

But that early plant has the capacity to remove only 4,000 tons of carbon dioxide per year — equivalent to the emissions from 870 cars — and Climeworks’s current costs are around \$600 to

### Biden is hiking the cost of carbon. It will change how the

“A new social cost of carbon can tip the scales for hundreds of policy decisions facing the federal government,” said Tamma Carleton, assistant professor at the Bren School of Environmental

### Cost plunges for capturing carbon dioxide from the air

Pulling carbon dioxide (CO 2) from the air and using it to make synthetic fuel seems like the ultimate solution to climate change: Instead of adding ever more CO 2 to the air from fossil fuels, we can simply recycle the same CO 2 molecules over and over. But such technology is expensive—about \$600 per ton of CO 2, by one recent estimate.Now, in a new study, scientists say future chemical

### Carbon Capture And Storage: An Expensive Option For

New analysis by Energy Innovation shows that carbon capture and storage is a considerably more expensive emissions reduction option than onshore wind power and solar photovoltaics (PV), and it is

### PDF Establishing a Value of Carbon

2. The social cost of carbon shall serve as a monetary estimate of the value of not emitting a ton of greenhouse gas emissions. As determined by the Department, the social cost of carbon may be based on marginal greenhouse gas abatement costs or on the global economic, environmental, and social

### Carbon steel pipe price | Carbon steel pipe price list

API 5L/ASTM A53 GR.B, ERW Carbon Steel Pipe Price List May 10th-May 16th, 2021 Date: 2021-05-09 View(s): 253 Tag: API 5L/ASTM A53 GR.B, ERW Carbon Steel Pipe Price List May 10th-May 16th, 2021 API 5L/ASTM A53 GR.B, ERW Carbon Steel Pipe Price List May 10th-May 16th, 2021

### PDF HYDROGEN STRATEGY – Energy

fuels with biomass and plastics is expected to be the lowest-cost route to providing carbon negative hydrogen when using carbon capture, utilization, and storage (CCUS) technologies. Scientists have been interested in hydrogen as a source of energy since the 1800s,1 and it is currently an essential feedstock and fuel in many industries.

### What is a carbon price and why do we need one? – Grantham

A carbon price is a cost applied to carbon pollution to encourage polluters to reduce the amount of greenhouse gases﻿ they emit into the atmosphere. Economists widely agree that introducing a carbon price is the single most effective way for countries to reduce their emissions.

### There are two factories in a small town. Both of them

Both of them emit carbon dioxide into the air. Their current monthly emissions, as well as the total costs for reducing emissions in 20-ton increments, are listed in the tables below. Current emissions (tons/month) 120 \$50 \$150 Total cost of reducing emissions by 20 tons/month Total cost of reducing emissions by 40

### Economic Impacts of Carbon Dioxide Emissions Are Grossly

Even the best current estimates, according to the Environmental Protection Agency and the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, are likely underestimates. “If the social cost of carbon is